Position Summary
Old York seeks a Development Director who thrives on engaging the community and cultivating lasting relationships with individuals, local businesses, and regional and national donors, inspiring them to support Old York’s museums, collections, and programs. In partnership with the Executive Director and Board of Trustees, the Development Director manages the donor database, plans and leads fundraising and cultivation events, oversees volunteers, and shapes fundraising strategy while handling day-to-day appeals and stewardship.
Now is the time to join Old York! The Development Director position is poised to shape the organization’s future. Working at OYHS provides a unique opportunity to be part of a dynamic professional team, engage with and preserve southern Maine's most significant historical resources, build relationships in the Seacoast region and beyond over a shared love of its history and culture, and help advance Old York’s mission to connect people with York’s important role in the history of New England.
Key Responsibilities
Donor Cultivation and Fundraising (primary responsibility)
• Work with the Executive Director to establish annual fundraising goals and budgets.
• Build and manage a portfolio of regional and national individual, corporate, and foundation donors.
• Meet regularly with donors and prospects in person, by phone, Zoom, and at Old York sites and networking events.
• Develop and implement an annual fundraising plan for individual giving, business sponsorship, foundation support, and events, with goals set alongside the Executive Director and Board.
• Create cultivation and solicitation opportunities that involve the Executive Director, Trustees, and staff, and prepare them for donor conversations.
• Write and coordinate appeals, donor communications and acknowledgments, and stewardship reports, and maintain a giving cycle calendar.
• Meet annual fundraising goals.
Database and Donor Communications
• Maximize the donor database by accurately and promptly entering records and gift entries.
• Track donor interactions and moves management so that each relationship has a clear next step.
• Produce regular fundraising reports for the Executive Director, Board, and accounting staff, and reconcile gift records with accounting.
• Use the database and email tools such as Constant Contact to segment audiences for appeals and event invitations.
• Ensure timely, accurate gift acknowledgments and tax receipts.
Event Planning
• Plan and execute Old York's fundraising and donor cultivation events from concept to completion, including budgets, sponsorships, invitations, logistics, and follow-up.
• Secure sponsorships and in-kind donations of goods and services to support events.
• Recruit, train, schedule, and thank event volunteers, and work with volunteer event committees.
• Evaluate each event's cost, revenue, and donor engagement to guide future planning.
• Coordinate with Education, Membership, and Visitor Services staff on member events and community programs that support fundraising goals.
Other
• Stay current on fundraising practices, donor privacy, and Maine charitable solicitation rules.
• Collaborate with Old York’s content and marketing teams to create meaningful experiences and communications that are relevant to the organization’s mission.
• Perform other duties as assigned in support of Old York's mission.
Qualifications
Required
• At least 2 years of fundraising experience.
• A proven track record of raising money, including soliciting and closing gifts from individuals and corporations.
• Exceptional verbal and written communication skills, with the ability to connect with people of all ages and backgrounds.
• Experience planning and managing fundraising events.
• Experience recruiting and managing volunteers.
• Strong organizational skills and attention to detail.
• The ability to collaborate across diverse teams, including staff, Trustees, volunteers, and community partners.
• Integrity and discretion in handling confidential donor information.
• Availability for some evenings and weekends, especially during the summer season and events.
Preferred
• Experience with Google Workspace, Microsoft Office, Little Green Light, and Constant Contact.
• A bachelor's degree, or an equivalent combination of education and experience.
• Experience in a museum, historical society, or other cultural nonprofit.
• Familiarity with York and the southern Maine philanthropic community.
• Interest in New England history.
Physical Requirements
The physical and mental demands described here are representative of those that must be met by an employee to perform the essential functions of this class successfully. Reasonable accommodations may be made to enable individuals with disabilities to perform the essential functions.
• Ability to move around historic buildings and grounds, indoors and out, including uneven floors, stairs, and outdoor terrain.
• A mix of desk work at a computer and phone and time out of the office meeting donors and attending events.
• Regional travel to donor meetings and Old York properties; a valid driver's license and reliable transportation.
• Sufficient speech and hearing are needed to convey and receive information over the phone, during video calls, and in person.
Compensation and How to Apply
The salary for this full-time position is $54,080 per year, and the position includes healthcare benefits.
To apply, send a cover letter and resume to jobs@oldyork.org. Old York Historical Society is an Equal Opportunity Employer.